01 · The Perspective
The wire that was meant to be temporary
The story below is illustrative. It is not about a real place.
A small factory adds a new machine before a big order. There is no spare circuit, so an electrician runs a temporary line from the main board. It works. The order ships on time, and everyone is relieved.
Two years later the "temporary" line is still there. More machines have been added to it. Nobody remembers who installed it or what it was rated for. Then, one hot afternoon, it fails.
The fix was clever. The failure was not that someone improvised. It was that nobody owned the job of turning the improvisation into something safe and permanent.
02 · The Perspective
The hidden cost of permanent patches
The pattern shows up everywhere. A pothole is filled with gravel instead of the drainage beneath it being fixed. A startup ships messy code to meet a deadline and spends the next year firefighting. A municipal service runs on a spreadsheet one officer built, and stops when they are transferred.
Some of the cost is visible. Electrical short circuits caused 17.2% of accidental fire deaths in India in 2024, according to National Crime Records Bureau data. Much of it is invisible: repeated repairs, lost time, and the quiet assumption that things will always break.
03 · The Perspective
More is in place than we credit
India is building shared foundations that make better systems possible. The IndiaAI Mission is creating national compute, datasets and support for safe and trusted AI. The government's Karmayogi Competency Model lists creativity and innovation, project management and data analytics among the capabilities expected of civil servants.
Abroad, two traditions show how to learn from failure. Toyota's continuous improvement turns every problem into a change in the standard way of working. Aviation shares incident reports across airlines, so one near miss becomes everyone's lesson.
04 · The Perspective
Why fixes stay temporary
- Fixes are not written down. The knowledge lives in one person's head.
- Root causes stay hidden. The symptom is treated, so it comes back.
- Nobody owns the upgrade. No one's job is to turn a workaround into a standard.
- Procurement rewards the cheapest option today, not the lowest cost over the life of the asset.
- Failure data is lost. Each breakdown is handled as if it were the first.
05 · The BIBD proposal
The redesign: a jugaad-to-standard funnel
A design to test. Not a claim of achieved outcomes.
Log every repeated workaround.
If the same fix happens three times, it enters a simple register with a named owner.
Review the root cause.
A short structured review asks why the failure happens, not just how it was patched.
Card the evidence.
Each promising fix gets a one-page record: what it does, what it costs and how it was tested.
Pass a reliability gate.
Before a fix becomes standard, it is checked for safety, maintenance and lifecycle cost.
Score scale-readiness.
The best fixes are documented so other sites can copy them.
This keeps what is good about jugaad, the speed and ingenuity of people closest to the problem, while giving the best ideas a path to last.
06 · Design + AI
Where AI helps, and where people decide
AI can mine maintenance logs and complaint records for repeated workarounds, group failures by likely root cause, compare failure histories across sites and flag unsafe patterns before they recur. Sensors and AI together make preventive maintenance practical: predicting a failure before it happens.
Decisions about safety and spending stay with the engineers and managers responsible for the asset.
07 · A testable next step
Start with twenty workarounds
One municipal service or one factory process can list its 20 most frequent workarounds and run them through the funnel for 60 days. Our planning estimate is ₹10 to 18 lakh.
The measures that matter are repeat failures eliminated, time between breakdowns, lifecycle cost, safety incidents and the share of workarounds turned into standards.
08 · Who must act
What each of us can do
| Founders and factory owners | list the three fixes your team repeats every month, and assign each an owner. |
|---|---|
| Municipal engineers | fix the cause, such as drainage, not only the surface. |
| Procurement teams | compare options on lifecycle cost, not purchase price alone. |
| Policy makers | reward prevention in budgets and performance reviews, not only quick response. |
| Every worker | take pride in the fire that never started. |
09 · The Perspective
Keep the ingenuity, lose the fragility
Jugaad is a strength worth keeping. But a country growing as fast as India needs its best improvisations to become systems that keep working at scale. The skill is not in making do. It is in making it last.