Perspective 13Education & Careers

Exams That Filter Instead of Grow

Every year, crores of Indian students sit high-stakes exams designed to sort them, not to help them learn. In an age when recall is cheap, an exam that mainly tests memory measures the wrong thing.

One day decides

The story below is illustrative. It is not about a real person.

A student who builds a working water filter for her village in Class 9 freezes in her Class 10 science exam and scores poorly. The exam asked her to recall definitions, not to design anything. Her filter does not appear on any certificate.

Her classmate memorises every past paper and scores in the nineties. Two years later, in college, he struggles with his first open-ended project.

The exam measured something. It just was not what either of them would need.

The scale of the trap

A Ministry of Education analysis of 59 school boards, reported in August 2024, found that more than 65 lakh students did not clear Class 10 and 12 in 2023. In Class 10, 28 lakh failed and 5.5 lakh did not appear. In Class 12, 27.2 lakh failed and 5.2 lakh did not appear.

Lakhs fail the boards every year

Failure rates in Class 10 and 12 board exams, 2023

Class 10, state boards16%
Class 10, national boards6%
Class 12, state boards18%
Class 12, national boards12%

Bars start at zero.

Failure rates were much higher in state boards. Source: Ministry of Education analysis, via PTI and The Week, August 2024.

Source: Ministry of Education analysis of 59 boards, via PTI and The Week, August 2024. Better India By Design. See article sources →

Separate board populations and classes, not a single share-of-total composition.

View original chart →

Behind every number is a young person who may stop studying altogether.

More is in place than most people know

  • A policy for change. The National Education Policy 2020 calls for board exams that test core capacities rather than rote learning, and for chances to improve scores.
  • A national assessment centre. PARAKH was set up to set standards for assessment across boards.
  • Two board exams. Moves to let students take board exams more than once a year reduce the weight of a single day.
  • Competency-based questions. National boards are increasing the share of application-based questions.

The direction is clear. The design of everyday assessment has not yet caught up.

Why exams trap students

  • One high-stakes day. A year of learning is judged in three hours.
  • Recall over reasoning. Questions reward memorisation and speed.
  • Marks without feedback. Students learn their score, not what to improve.
  • Fear of failure. With everything riding on one result, nobody experiments.
  • Different standards. The same student can pass in one board and fail in another.

The redesign: capability-first assessment

A design to test. Not a claim of achieved outcomes.

  1. Continuous learning loops.

    Short, low-stakes checks through the year, with feedback, replace the weight of one final day.

  2. Projects and portfolios.

    Students show what they can build, investigate and explain, and that work counts.

  3. Feedback that helps.

    Every assessment tells the student what to do next, not just a number.

  4. Real-world tasks.

    Questions ask students to apply ideas to problems from their own lives and community.

  5. Common standards.

    Boards align on what a pass means, so a student's future does not depend on which board they sat.

Where AI helps, and where teachers decide

AI can map each student's progress across the year, suggest practice for gaps, generate varied application questions and help teachers give faster written feedback.

Teachers decide what a student's work means, and high-stakes results are never decided by AI alone. Students and parents can always see and question how a mark was given.

Start with one district's Class 9

One district's Class 9 students in a group of schools can run a one-year pilot: monthly low-stakes checks with feedback, one community project per term and a simple portfolio. Our planning estimate is ₹40 to 70 lakh.

The measures that matter are learning gains across the year, students who stay in school, student anxiety and teachers' confidence in using feedback.

What each of us can do

Who can act and the next step
The Ministry of Education and PARAKHpublish how much each board's exams test application, not only results.
State boardsmove a share of marks to continuous assessment and projects.
Schoolsgive feedback on every test, not just marks.
Teachersreplace one memory test per term with a problem to solve.
Parentsask what your child learned from a test, not only what they scored.

Measure what matters

India's students are capable of far more than its exams record. Assessment designed to grow capability, rather than to filter, would let that capability show.

Watch the full episode →

Redesigning Indian Education: The Exam Trap

Your turn: if you could change one thing about how Indian students are tested, what would it be? Tell us in the comments on the video, and subscribe to Better India By Design for the next redesign.

Watch on YouTube →

Sources and notes

Figures reflect the periods, populations and definitions in the cited material. They are not live totals.

  1. 01
    The Week (PTI), "65 lakh students did not clear Class 10, 12 in 2023; failure rates higher in state boards: MoE", 21 August 2024. Link

If exam pressure is affecting you or someone you know, Tele-MANAS offers free support at 14416.

Pilot costs are Better India By Design planning estimates, not government figures.

Researched with AI assistance. Facts checked against the cited sources and reviewed by the BIBD Editorial Team.

BIBD proposals are designs to test, not claims of achieved outcomes. Pilot costs are planning estimates unless a source states otherwise.

Website edition prepared from the supplied Perspective on 31 October 2026. Original document →

Continue reading

Another system. A connected question.