Perspective 11Farming & Rural

Farmers Carry the Risk. The Chain Keeps the Value.

Indian farmers take the weather risk, the price risk and the debt. Between their field and the plate, much of the value leaks away to spoilage, opaque prices and long chains of middlemen.

A good harvest, a bad price

The story below is illustrative. It is not about a real person.

A tomato farmer has his best harvest in years. So does everyone else in his district. The trader at the market offers a price below his cost of picking. There is no cold storage nearby, and tomatoes will not wait. He sells, or he dumps.

Three weeks later, tomato prices in the city spike. By then, his crop is gone. He took every risk; someone else captured the gain.

Value lost after harvest

A study by NABCONS for the Ministry of Food Processing Industries, covering 2020–22, estimated post-harvest losses at about ₹1.53 lakh crore a year. The highest losses were in perishables: about 15% of guava, 11.6% of tomatoes and 9.5% of apples and sapota.

Fruit, vegetables and fish lose most after harvest

Post-harvest loss, share of production (highest-loss items), 2020–22

Guavaabout 15%
Tomato11.6%
Apple9.5%
Sapota9.5%
Marine fish8.8%

Bars start at zero.

Perishables lose the most between farm and market. Source: NABCONS for MoFPI, 2022, via Dataful.

Source: NABCONS study for the Ministry of Food Processing Industries, 2022, via Dataful. Better India By Design. See article sources →

Selected high-loss items only. Different crop production denominators, not shares of a combined total.

View original chart →

Every tonne lost is income a farmer never receives and food a family never eats.

More is in place than most people know

  • A national electronic market. e-NAM links mandis so buyers in other places can bid for produce.
  • Farmer producer organisations. Thousands of FPOs let small farmers pool produce and bargain together.
  • Cold-chain support. Government schemes co-fund cold storage, pack houses and processing.
  • Price and weather information. Agmarknet and weather advisories reach farmers by app and SMS.

The gap is that these pieces are not designed as one chain from the farmer's decision to the buyer's plate.

Where value leaks

  • Too many hands. Produce passes through several intermediaries, each taking a margin.
  • Prices farmers cannot see. A farmer rarely knows today's price in other markets before he sells.
  • No time to wait. Without storage or credit against stored produce, farmers must sell at harvest, when prices are lowest.
  • Everyone plants the same crop. Without demand signals, gluts follow good prices, and prices collapse.
  • Band-aids instead of design. Loan waivers and emergency procurement treat symptoms, not the chain.

The redesign: three blueprints for farm income

A design to test. Not a claim of achieved outcomes.

  1. Direct, transparent procurement.

    FPOs sell directly to processors, retailers and institutions through contracts with visible prices.

  2. Predictive logistics and cold chain.

    Forecast what will be harvested where and route it to storage or buyers before it spoils.

  3. Data-driven crop and sale decisions.

    Give farmers demand and price forecasts before sowing and before selling, in their language.

  4. Stronger collectives.

    Fund FPOs to provide shared grading, storage and finance against stored produce.

Where AI helps, and where farmers decide

AI can forecast prices and demand, match produce to buyers, plan routes so trucks are full and perishables move first, and spot crop disease from a phone photograph.

Farmers decide what to grow and when to sell. Forecasts are advice, shown with their uncertainty, and no farmer's data is sold without consent.

Start with one district and one crop

One district, one perishable crop such as tomato, and two or three FPOs can run a one-season pilot: harvest forecasts, linked storage, direct buyers and price alerts. Our planning estimate is ₹50 lakh to ₹1 crore.

The measures that matter are the farmer's share of the final price, produce lost after harvest, distress sales at harvest and net income per acre.

What each of us can do

Who can act and the next step
The Ministry of Agriculture and the Ministry of Food Processing Industriespublish post-harvest loss and farmer share of price by crop and state.
FPOspool storage and sell on contract, not only at the mandi.
e-NAM and agri-startupsshow farmers prices across markets before they sell.
Cold-chain operatorslocate storage near clusters of perishable crops.
Consumersbuy from farmer collectives where you can.

Keep the value with the grower

India's farmers already produce enough to feed the country. The next step is a chain designed so that more of what they grow reaches buyers, and more of what buyers pay reaches farmers.

Watch the full episode →

Redesigning Indian Farming: The Farmer Income Trap

Your turn: where do you think a farmer loses the most money: before harvest, at harvest or after? Tell us in the comments on the video, and subscribe to Better India By Design for the next redesign.

Watch on YouTube →

Sources and notes

Figures reflect the periods, populations and definitions in the cited material. They are not live totals.

  1. 01
    Dataful, "From guava to milk: what food loss reveals about India's supply chains", on the NABCONS study for the Ministry of Food Processing Industries, 2022. Link

Pilot costs are Better India By Design planning estimates, not government figures.

Researched with AI assistance. Facts checked against the cited sources and reviewed by the BIBD Editorial Team.

BIBD proposals are designs to test, not claims of achieved outcomes. Pilot costs are planning estimates unless a source states otherwise.

Website edition prepared from the supplied Perspective on 31 October 2026. Original document →

Continue reading

Another system. A connected question.