Perspective 42Cities and infrastructure

A new road should stay new.

Ending Bengaluru’s dig–repair–dig cycle.

Bengaluru does not lack road budgets or pothole drives. It lacks a rule that makes the agency that cuts a road pay to make it whole.

One night on the Outer Ring Road

On the night of 2 July 2026, Karnataka's minister for Greater Bengaluru development inspected the Outer Ring Road between Lowry Junction and Silk Board. He found a service road that had just been asphalted, already cut open. City corporation officials said BESCOM had done it.

BESCOM denied it. Officers from the road owner, the power utility, the water board, the metro and the traffic police were all present, and none of them could say which agency had dug the trench. [1]

Every Bengaluru commuter knows the sequence that follows. A smooth new surface, then a trench, then a patch that sits slightly above the road, then a pothole at the edge of that patch by the next monsoon. Each agency had a legitimate reason to be there.

The person on a two-wheeler still ends up on a road that never stays fixed.

The money is being spent

The commitment, in numbers.

Asphalting programme

₹1,600crore

White-topping programme

₹1,700crore

Reported programme values, not audited expenditure or achieved outcomes. Source: The New Indian Express, 7 December 2025. [2] [9]

This is not a city that ignores its roads. By December 2025 the civic authorities reported 1,682 km of arterial and sub-arterial roads under the Greater Bengaluru Authority, with a ₹1,600 crore asphalting programme and a ₹1,700 crore white-topping programme under way. In October 2026 an AI survey of the North City Corporation's roads counted 14,393 potholes across 2,493.5 km.

The survey placed utility-related works in a single 17.9% group alongside localised damage and unpaved roads. [2] [3]

That last detail matters. Nobody publishes how many cuts happen on roads that were resurfaced in the last year, how many of those cuts had a permit, or how many potholes begin at the edge of a utility patch. A city that cannot count re-cuts cannot put a price on them.

The cost is not only inconvenience.

Reported deaths in pothole-related road accidents

53%increase from 2020 to 2024
9,438 people killed over the five years
20201,555
20211,481
20221,856
20232,161
20242,385
Source: PTI / Siasat, 14 February 2026, reporting the Ministry of Road Transport and Highways’ reply in Parliament. Bars start at zero; percentage change is rounded. These are national figures—not Bengaluru-only deaths, and not all attributable to utility cuts. [4]

The cost is not only inconvenience. Data tabled in Parliament put pothole-related road deaths across India at 2,385 in 2024 and 9,438 between 2020 and 2024. Not every pothole starts with a utility cut, but every badly restored cut is a pothole waiting for rain. [4]

Fifteen years of coordination, and the same trench

Bengaluru has tried to fix this before. An online road-cutting permission system was introduced in 2015. A state audit later found utility maps incomplete and coordination weak.

In July 2026 the GBA announced a GIS road history platform where departments would upload annual works plans and give six months' notice, along with a monthly coordination committee chaired by the minister. The East and North corporations now run dashcam surveys that can detect utility cuts automatically. [5] [6]

Each of these helps. Each of them is also about information: maps, permits, dashboards and notice periods. What none of them does is change what happens to the agency that cuts a new road without warning.

Declaring a planned work is optional in practice, and staying silent costs nothing. The patch fails months later, when it shows up as a pothole on the road owner's books rather than the cutter's.

The problem is usually described as agencies not talking to each other. A more useful description is that talking is optional and silence is free.

What other cities do

Singapore applies a one-year "no-opening" moratorium to newly resurfaced roads, with exceptions for emergencies. When a utility does need to dig, it pays the full cost of re-excavation and resurfacing, so the taxpayer pays nothing extra. A Road Opening Coordination Committee, chaired by the Land Transport Authority, sequences works across agencies.

England's street works permit schemes attach conditions and fines to every permit, and a government evaluation found shorter utility works and thousands of days of road occupation saved through joint works. [7] [8]

The lesson for Bengaluru is less about tunnels or technology and more about two rules: protect what you have just paved, and make the cost follow the cut.

The Cut-Cost Protocol

A design to test. Not a claim of achieved outcomes.

We propose a set of rules and a light data layer on top of the platforms Bengaluru already has. It does not replace the GBA road history platform, the telecom right-of-way portal or the national Call Before u Dig app. It gives them consequences.

The proposed sequence

  1. 01DeclareBefore paving
  2. 02ProtectThe new surface
  3. 03TraceEvery cut
  4. 04VerifyThe restoration
  5. 05ShowThe public
Five linked duties. One accountable road record. A design to test, not a measured result.
  1. Declare before we pave.

    Before a resurfacing tender is awarded, every utility and project agency declares the work it expects on that corridor in the next 24 months. Declared works are bundled into a joint window before the new surface goes down. Silence is recorded as "no planned work".

  2. Protect what we paved.

    A newly resurfaced segment enters a protected period, for example 12 months for asphalt. Emergency repairs always go ahead. Any cut in that period must restore the full lane panel, not a trench-width patch, and an undeclared planned cut also pays a protected-road charge.

  3. Trace every cut.

    Each road segment already has, or can be given, a Road Identification Number. Every permit and every cut detected by the survey vehicles is linked to that number, so a trench on the ground can be matched to a permit within days.

  4. Check the patch over time.

    The cutting agency uploads photos at handover, and survey imagery re-checks the patch at about 3 and 12 months. A failed patch is reopened at the cutter's cost.

  5. Show the public.

    Every work site carries a printed board in Kannada and English, with a QR code, showing who is digging, under which permit, the restoration deadline and a number to report problems.

Where AI helps, and where it must not decide

No team of engineers can inspect thousands of kilometres of road every month. Survey vehicles with computer vision can, and Bengaluru's corporations already use them. AI makes the protocol enforceable by detecting cuts, matching them to permits and flagging the ones that match nothing.

It must not issue fines. A ward engineer verifies detections before any charge, an unmatched cut gets a fixed window to show its permit, and faces and number plates are blurred at capture.

Human judgement remains the boundary.AI flags. A ward engineer verifies. Fines are never automatic.

Start with one batch of roads

50–100 km

One resurfacing batch

12 months

Proposed pilot period

₹60–90 lakh

BIBD planning estimate

Proposed scope and coordination-layer cost from this Perspective. Not government figures or a funded commitment.

This does not need a citywide launch. One city corporation can volunteer its next resurfacing batch of 50 to 100 km, run a declaration sweep before the tender, protect the new surface for a year, and compare re-cuts against a similar batch that follows today's process. Our planning estimate for the coordination layer is ₹60 to 90 lakh for 12 months, small next to the ₹3,300 crore being spent on surfaces.

Success should be measured in cuts per 100 km on protected roads, the share of cuts matched to a permit, and patches still intact after a year. It should not be measured in potholes filled or dashboards launched.

Measure the road, not the dashboard.

  1. Cuts per 100 km on protected roads.
  2. Share of cuts matched to a permit.
  3. Patches still intact after a year.

What each of us can do

Specific asks for each stakeholder
WhoThe next step
GBAadd protected-period expiry, permit ID per cut and reinstatement result to the road history platform.
City corporationsvolunteer one resurfacing batch for a 12-month pilot.
Utilities and telecom operatorspublish 24-month works plans for pilot corridors.
Urban Development Departmentdraft a rule that makes restoration cost follow the cutter on protected roads.
Residents' associationsadopt a corridor and report unmarked trenches.

A new road should stay new

Bengaluru has already spent the money, run the drives and built the surveys. What it has not done is attach a name and a cost to every cut. Declare before we pave, protect what we paved, trace every cut and charge the cutter.

Coordination then becomes the cheaper choice for every agency, and the road stays smooth for the person riding on it.

Episode 42 thumbnail: Road resurfaced. Weeks later, it’s cut open again.Watch the full episode

Redesigning Bengaluru Roads:
The Dig–Repair–Dig Trap

Which road near you was dug up within weeks of being resurfaced? Share the location in the episode’s comments.

Watch on YouTube
Watch the 60-second version →

Sources and notes

Figures reflect the places, periods and definitions in the cited sources. They are not live totals.

  1. 01
  2. 02
  3. 03
  4. 04
  5. 05
  6. 06
  7. 07
  8. 08
  9. 09

Costs for the proposed pilot are Better India By Design planning estimates, not government figures. The Cut-Cost Protocol is a proposal to test, not a claim of achieved impact.

View the original Perspective →

Continue reading

Another system. A connected question.