Perspective 12Cities & Environment

Wider Roads Will Not Save Indian Cities

We are told traffic comes from too many cars and that wider roads are the cure. Decades of evidence say wider roads fill up again. The real problem is that public transport is too unreliable to beat the car.

The 40-minute, 10-kilometre commute

The story below is illustrative. It is not about a real person.

A software engineer lives 10 km from her office. The metro station is 2 km from her home, with no footpath and no reliable bus. So she rides a scooter. On a good day, the trip takes 35 minutes. On a bad day, it takes over an hour.

She would happily take the metro if she could get to it safely and quickly. The city has built the metro. It has not built the walk, the bus or the single ticket that would make it her first choice.

The cost in hours

The TomTom Traffic Index for 2025 ranked Bengaluru the world's second most congested city, with an average congestion level of 74.4% and an average speed of 16.6 km/h. Drivers in Bengaluru lost about 168 hours in the year, in Pune 152 and in Mumbai 126. India ranked fifth among countries for congestion.

Days of every year spent in traffic

Hours lost to congestion per driver in 2025 (TomTom Traffic Index)

Bengaluru168 hours
Pune152 hours
Mumbai126 hours

Bars start at zero.

Hours lost to congestion in 2025. Source: TomTom Traffic Index 2025, via Down To Earth.

Source: TomTom Traffic Index 2025, via Down To Earth. Better India By Design. See article sources →

Congestion hours per driver for 2025; not total city working time.

View original chart →

168 hours is seven full days of every year spent in traffic.

More is in place than most commuters know

  • Metro networks. A growing number of Indian cities have metro lines operating or under construction.
  • Common mobility cards. The National Common Mobility Card allows one card across metro, bus and other services where cities have adopted it.
  • Policy direction. National transit-oriented development and urban transport policies already favour public transport, walking and cycling over road widening.
  • Data. Cities have traffic cameras, GPS on buses and metro ridership data.

The pieces exist. They are not yet designed as one system around the traveller.

Why the car keeps winning

  • The first and last kilometre. Stations are hard to reach on foot, and feeder buses are unreliable.
  • Many tickets, many apps. Switching modes means switching payments and timetables.
  • Unreliable buses. Without dedicated lanes and real-time information, buses are stuck in the same traffic as cars.
  • Fixed signals. Many signals run on fixed timings regardless of actual traffic.
  • Free or cheap parking. Parking policy quietly subsidises driving.
  • Wider roads. New lanes fill with new traffic within a few years.

The redesign: a connected mobility system

A design to test. Not a claim of achieved outcomes.

  1. Last-mile hubs.

    Every metro station gets safe walking routes, shared bicycles and feeder buses timed to trains.

  2. One ticket, one app.

    A single fare and journey planner across metro, bus and last-mile services.

  3. Buses that beat the car on reliability.

    Dedicated lanes on key corridors and live arrival information.

  4. Signals that respond.

    Adaptive signals that adjust to real traffic and give priority to buses.

  5. Safe walking and cycling.

    Continuous footpaths and protected cycle lanes around stations and schools.

  6. Managed parking.

    Priced parking in busy areas, with the revenue reinvested in transit.

Where AI helps, and where planners decide

AI can predict congestion, adjust signal timings in real time, forecast demand so buses run where and when people need them, and plan multi-mode journeys for travellers.

Decisions about road space, fares and priorities remain with city planners and elected bodies, and travel data is anonymised and used only to improve the service.

Start with one corridor

One busy corridor with a metro line can run a twelve-month pilot: last-mile hubs at five stations, feeder buses timed to trains, one ticket and adaptive signals. Our planning estimate is ₹5 to 10 crore, excluding major civil works.

The measures that matter are door-to-door travel time, the share of trips by public transport, bus reliability and pedestrian safety on the corridor.

What each of us can do

Who can act and the next step
The Ministry of Housing and Urban Affairsfund last-mile connectivity alongside every metro line.
Metro corporations and city bus undertakingstime feeder buses to trains and share one ticket.
Traffic policepilot adaptive signals with bus priority on one corridor.
Urban plannersstop treating road widening as the default answer.
Commuterstry one public transport trip a week, and report what made it hard.

Design the trip, not the road

Indian cities cannot widen their way out of congestion. They can design a system in which the reliable, affordable choice is also the obvious one. When public transport beats the car on certainty, people switch.

Watch the full episode →

Redesigning Indian Traffic: The Mobility Illusion

Your turn: what would make you leave your car or bike at home for a week? Tell us in the comments on the video, and subscribe to Better India By Design for the next redesign.

Watch on YouTube →

Sources and notes

Figures reflect the periods, populations and definitions in the cited material. They are not live totals.

  1. 01
    Down To Earth, "Bengaluru, Kolkata among world's slowest cities as India ranks high on congestion index", on the TomTom Traffic Index 2025. Link

Pilot costs are Better India By Design planning estimates, not government figures.

Researched with AI assistance. Facts checked against the cited sources and reviewed by the BIBD Editorial Team.

BIBD proposals are designs to test, not claims of achieved outcomes. Pilot costs are planning estimates unless a source states otherwise.

Website edition prepared from the supplied Perspective on 31 October 2026. Original document →

Continue reading

Another system. A connected question.