Perspective 44Cities & Environment · Justice & Public Services

Closed Is Not the Same as Fixed

The complaint is closed. The pothole opens again next week. Drains flood again, streetlights fail again. The issue is not only slow action. It is data that lets a ticket close while the problem remains.

The same pothole, five times

The story below is illustrative. It is not about a real street.

A resident reports a pothole outside her lane. Three days later, the complaint is marked resolved. A thin patch of tar has been laid. After the next rain, the pothole is back. She complains again; a new ticket opens and closes.

By the end of the year, the same pothole has generated five resolved complaints. The city's dashboard shows five successes.

Fast closure, unknown outcomes

According to a written reply in the Rajya Sabha, reported by PTI in July 2025, central ministries and departments received 6,60,091 grievances on CPGRAMS between 1 April and 24 July 2025 and redressed 4,47,431, with an average redressal time of 16 days. A feedback call centre has run since July 2022 to check citizen satisfaction.

Speed has improved. The harder question is how many problems stay solved.

More is in place than most citizens use

  • CPGRAMS. The national online grievance system for central ministries, with appeals and feedback.
  • State grievance portals. Many states run their own, such as Karnataka's Janaspandana.
  • Municipal complaint apps. Most cities accept complaints by app, phone or web.
  • Feedback calls. Some systems call citizens to check satisfaction after closure.

Where resolution breaks

  • Repeat complaints are separate tickets, so recurring failures are hidden.
  • "Resolved" is not defined. A temporary patch counts the same as a permanent repair.
  • No evidence of work. Closures do not record location, asset, material or sign-off.
  • Safety and repair are mixed. A barricade may close a ticket meant for a repair.
  • Dashboards reward closures, not lasting fixes.

The redesign: engineering permanent fixes

A design to test. Not a claim of achieved outcomes.

  1. A Shared Service Incident ID that links repeat complaints to one underlying failure.

  2. A Resolution Contract defining what "fixed" means for each type of problem.

  3. Evidence of work: location, asset, material, time and sign-off for every closure.

  4. Temporary safety action kept separate from permanent repair.

  5. Dashboards that reward fewer repeat complaints, not more tickets closed.

Where AI helps, and where people decide

AI can detect recurring failures, flag weak closures and reveal hidden infrastructure priorities from complaint patterns.

Engineers decide how to fix the problem. Citizens confirm whether it stayed fixed.

Start with one city's roads and drains

One city can pilot shared incident IDs and resolution contracts for roads and drains for a year. Our planning estimate is ₹40 to 60 lakh.

The measures that matter are repeat complaints for the same asset, time to permanent fix and citizen-confirmed resolutions.

What each of us can do

Who can act and the next step
Citizensreopen a complaint if the problem returns, and mention the old complaint number.
DARPGadd repeat-complaint tracking to CPGRAMS.
State grievance cellsdefine what "resolved" means for common problems.
Municipal corporations and engineering departmentsrecord evidence of work for every closure.
Elected representativesask for repeat-complaint data, not only closure rates.

Fixed means fixed

A grievance system should be judged by how few people need to complain twice. That requires data that tracks the problem, not just the ticket.

Watch the full episode →

Redesigning Indian Grievance Systems: Engineering Permanent Fixes

Your turn: what complaint have you filed that was marked "resolved" but was not? Tell us in the comments on the video, and subscribe to Better India By Design for the next redesign.

Watch on YouTube → Play Mission 44

The Pothole That Came Back

5–7 minutes · Grade 8 and up

Play Mission 44

Sources and notes

Figures reflect the periods, populations and definitions in the cited material. They are not live totals.

  1. 01
    The Week (PTI), "4.47 lakh out of 6.6 lakh public grievances received in past four months redressed: Govt", 31 July 2025. Link

Pilot costs are Better India By Design planning estimates, not government figures.

Researched with AI assistance. Facts checked against the cited sources and reviewed by the BIBD Editorial Team.

BIBD proposals are designs to test, not claims of achieved outcomes. Pilot costs are planning estimates unless a source states otherwise.

Website edition prepared from the supplied Perspective on 31 October 2026. Original document →

Continue reading

Another system. A connected question.