Perspective 17Cities & Environment · Justice & Public Services

A Waitlist Is a Demand Signal, Not a Verdict

Every unconfirmed ticket tells Indian Railways exactly where, when and how many people wanted to travel. Today that information mostly turns into cancellations and refunds.

Refreshing the app at midnight

The story below is illustrative. It is not about a real person.

A construction worker in Mumbai needs to get home to Bihar for a family wedding. He books two months ahead and gets waitlist number 147. Every day he checks the status. It moves to 62, then stops.

On the day before travel, he tries Tatkal and loses to faster connections. His ticket is cancelled automatically, and he gets a refund minus charges. He travels in an overcrowded general coach for thirty hours, standing for much of it.

Railways knew, two months earlier, that he and thousands like him wanted that journey.

A queue that keeps growing

An RTI reply to activist Chandra Shekhar Gaur, reported in May 2026, shows how many waitlisted passengers could not travel because their tickets were not confirmed: 1.65 crore in 2021-22, rising each year to over 3.39 crore in 2025-26.

More passengers left behind every year

Passengers whose waitlisted tickets were never confirmed, by financial year

2021–22about 1.65 crore
2022–232.72 crore
2023–242.96 crore
2024–253.27 crore
2025–26over 3.39 crore

Bars start at zero.

Waitlisted passengers whose tickets were not confirmed, by year. Source: RTI reply reported by Curly Tales, May 2026.

Source: Indian Railways RTI replies to Chandra Shekhar Gaur, via Curly Tales, May 2026. Better India By Design. See article sources →

Financial years. First and final values are approximate; never convert to more precise totals.

View original chart →

Each of those is a person who wanted to travel by train, was willing to pay and could not.

More is in place than most passengers know

  • One national booking system. IRCTC and the Passenger Reservation System hold years of detailed booking and cancellation data.
  • Alternate train options. Schemes such as VIKALP let waitlisted passengers opt for seats on other trains on the same route.
  • Special and extra coaches. Railways adds coaches and runs special trains during festivals.
  • Chart preparation. Reservation charts are prepared before departure, and vacant berths can be allocated through the system.

Where the system breaks

  • Demand is recorded but not used. Waitlists are cleared by cancellation, not answered with capacity.
  • Tatkal rewards speed, not need. The fastest connection wins, which favours agents and bots.
  • Empty seats travel. Some berths booked but not used are not reallocated in time.
  • Planning reacts late. Festival specials are often announced after people have already given up on the train.
  • The journey starts before the platform. Getting to the station, finding the coach and carrying luggage are left to the passenger.

The redesign: a predictive railway grid

A design to test. Not a claim of achieved outcomes.

  1. Waitlists as demand signals.

    Publish route-wise waitlist data and use it to add coaches or trains weeks ahead, not days.

  2. Fairer Tatkal.

    Verified identity, limits per account and a short ballot window instead of a pure speed race.

  3. Reallocate unused seats.

    Release berths automatically once a passenger has clearly not boarded, to the next person on the waitlist.

  4. Capacity follows demand.

    Plan festival and seasonal capacity from booking patterns, and announce it early.

  5. Door to coach.

    Show coach position, platform and last-mile options in one place, in every major Indian language.

Where AI helps, and where people decide

AI can forecast demand by route and date, predict which waitlisted tickets are likely to confirm, detect bot bookings and suggest where extra coaches would help most.

Railway officials decide timetables, safety and how scarce capacity is shared. Forecasts and allocation rules should be published so passengers can see they are fair.

Start with one corridor

One busy corridor, such as Mumbai to Bihar or Delhi to Uttar Pradesh, can run a festival-season pilot: weekly waitlist publishing, demand-led extra coaches and automatic reallocation of unused berths. Our planning estimate for the analytics and operations work is ₹2 to 3 crore, excluding the cost of rolling stock.

The measures that matter are passengers left unconfirmed, berths travelling empty, Tatkal tickets booked by verified individuals and how early extra capacity is announced.

What each of us can do

Who can act and the next step
Passengersopt for alternate trains when booking, and cancel early if your plans change.
The Railway Board and zonespublish waitlist data by route every month.
IRCTCpilot a fairer Tatkal window and stronger bot controls.
State governmentsshare festival travel forecasts with Railways early.
Researchersstudy waitlist data to show where capacity is most needed.

Every waitlist is a map

India already knows where its people want to go. A railway that listens to its own waitlist can move more of them, more fairly, without guessing.

Watch the full episode →

Redesigning Indian Railways: The Waitlist Lottery

Your turn: what is your worst waitlist or Tatkal story? Tell us in the comments on the video, and subscribe to Better India By Design for the next redesign.

Watch on YouTube →

Sources and notes

Figures reflect the periods, populations and definitions in the cited material. They are not live totals.

  1. 01
    Curly Tales, "Over 3 crore railway passengers couldn't travel due to unconfirmed tickets", May 2026, on an RTI reply to Chandra Shekhar Gaur. Link

Pilot costs are Better India By Design planning estimates, not government figures.

Researched with AI assistance. Facts checked against the cited sources and reviewed by the BIBD Editorial Team.

BIBD proposals are designs to test, not claims of achieved outcomes. Pilot costs are planning estimates unless a source states otherwise.

Website edition prepared from the supplied Perspective on 31 October 2026. Original document →

Continue reading

Another system. A connected question.