Perspective 9Justice & Public Services

Citizens Should Not Be Messengers Between Departments

A delayed permit, a missing signature, a trip from one office to another. We call it "the way things are". It is really a design failure that turns citizens into couriers for the government's own files.

The file that needs one more signature

The story below is illustrative. It is not about a real person.

A farmer inherits land after his father's death. To update the record, he needs a death certificate from the municipality, a family tree from the revenue office, a no-objection from his siblings and a signature from a village officer who is away at a training. Each office tells him what it needs from the next.

After eleven visits, the record still shows his father's name. When he applies for a crop loan, the bank asks for an updated record. He goes back to the first office.

The cost of silos

India's land records show how much depends on records that talk to each other. A [PRS Legislative Research analysis](https://PRSINDIA.org/files/policy/policy_analytical_reports/Land Records and Titles in India.pdf) notes estimates that land-related disputes account for about two-thirds of pending court cases, and that land disputes take about 20 years on average to resolve, citing NITI Aayog. It found that departments holding land information "work in silos", and that family transfers through inheritance often go unrecorded because registration is not mandatory for them.

Behind every long dispute is a record that was not updated, or two records that disagree.

More is in place than most citizens know

  • Digitised land records. The Digital India Land Records Modernisation Programme has digitised records and maps in most states.
  • Single windows. Many states run unified service portals and Common Service Centres for applications.
  • Grievance systems. The national grievance portal, CPGRAMS, routes complaints to the responsible ministry.
  • A standard for services. Citizens' charters and time-bound service laws exist in many states.

These are real gains. The gap is that each piece is owned by a different department, and nobody owns the citizen's whole journey.

Where the journey breaks

  • Departments as islands. Each office checks its own rules, then sends the citizen to the next.
  • No owner for the request. When it stalls, nobody is accountable for moving it.
  • Records that disagree. Revenue, registration and survey records may each say something different.
  • Digital-only paths. Welfare and services move online, leaving people without connectivity or literacy behind.
  • Policies untested. Rules are written and rolled out without watching a single citizen try to follow them.

The redesign: policy as citizen experience

A design to test. Not a claim of achieved outcomes.

  1. One owner per request.

    Every application has a named officer who is responsible until it is resolved, even when other departments must act.

  2. Records that talk.

    When one department updates a record, linked records update automatically, with the citizen informed.

  3. Faster mutation from verified events.

    A registered sale or a recorded death triggers the land record update, instead of waiting for the citizen to apply.

  4. One urban service window.

    A single counter or portal for related city services, with back-office routing.

  5. Offline routes that work.

    Assisted service through CSCs and village offices for anyone who cannot use an app.

  6. Test before rollout.

    Every new rule is tried with real citizens in one district before it goes statewide.

Where AI helps, and where people decide

AI can read scanned records and flag mismatches between departments, route requests to the right office, explain requirements in local languages and spot where applications commonly stall.

Officials stay accountable for every decision. AI recommends and routes; it never approves or rejects a citizen's claim, and every decision can be appealed.

Start with one service in one district

One district can redesign one service, such as land record mutation after inheritance, for six months: a named owner per request, linked records and assisted offline access. Our planning estimate is ₹25 to 40 lakh.

The measures that matter are days to completion, visits needed, documents asked for, requests completed first time and citizen satisfaction.

What each of us can do

Who can act and the next step
The Department of Administrative Reforms and Public Grievancesadd "visits and documents per service" to how states are assessed.
State governmentsname one officer accountable for each high-volume service journey end to end.
Land records departmentslink registration, revenue and survey records so one update flows to all.
District administrationstest every new scheme with ten real citizens before launch.
Citizensask for the name of the officer who owns your application.

Design the policy around the person

India's officials work hard inside systems that were never designed as one. When policy is treated as an experience a citizen must complete, the runaround becomes a design problem with a design solution.

Watch the full episode →

Redesigning Indian Bureaucracy: Policy as Citizen Experience

Your turn: which government process made you feel like a messenger between departments? Tell us in the comments on the video, and subscribe to Better India By Design for the next redesign.

Watch on YouTube →

Sources and notes

Figures reflect the periods, populations and definitions in the cited material. They are not live totals.

  1. 01
    PRS Legislative Research, "Land Records and Titles in India" (citing the World Bank and NITI Aayog). Link

Pilot costs are Better India By Design planning estimates, not government figures.

Researched with AI assistance. Facts checked against the cited sources and reviewed by the BIBD Editorial Team.

BIBD proposals are designs to test, not claims of achieved outcomes. Pilot costs are planning estimates unless a source states otherwise.

Website edition prepared from the supplied Perspective on 31 October 2026. Original document →

Continue reading

Another system. A connected question.